




by ScooterMy criteria may differ from yours a bit in that not all of these songs directly address a particular war as much as the state of mind that leads to war...
1: "What's Going On," Marvin Gaye. Why is this on top? The message is so powerful that Motown, at first, didn't want to release it. It addresses more than just Vietnam, but social/racial/economic divides as well. That would make it a great song no matter what, but combined with an irresistable dance groove...wow!
2: "Like A Rolling Stone," Bob Dylan. He wrote other great protest songs, too, of course..."Masters of War" comes to mind...but this one is his finest hour. The live version with The Band on "Before the Flood" is incredible.
3: "War," Edwin Starr. This song, along with others like "What's Going On," brought into sharp focus the role of black America in protesting Vietnam. Helluva funk groove (GREAT horns), and a great live cover version on Bruce Springsteen's live box set.
4: "Born in the USA," Bruce Springsteen. His most misunderstood and misused song. People hear the force of the arrangement with the E Street Band and consider it an anthem, when it's really an indictment of Vietnam and the treatment of veterans of that war. It made him a superstar, but my gut tells me he regrets the original arrangement as a result.
5: "Imagine," John Lennon. Speaks for itself.
Hard to leave Public Enemy's "Fight the Power" off this list; Pete Seeger's "If I Had A Hammer" wants in, too.
I continue to wonder when the music artists of today will REALLY take on the current world situation in a way that captures the public. A few have at least tried, not the least of which is Neil Young's "Living With War," but it isn't as though he's well known among the younger generation. Bruce had a golden opportunity with "We Shall Overcome," and it's a great CD, but he left off some potential songs that would have made it even better.
Name the biggest stars in the world today, and none of them have really even tried to earn a spot on a list like this. Pity.
EDITOR'S NOTE: If you would like to submit a Top Five post, just
send me an email.